Plainfield's Risky Finish
/Larry Dorman examines the big twist at Plainfield for The Barclays: the driveable 18th. Always the weak link in an otherwise fantastic Donald Ross design, Dorman tells the backstory of the decision to shorten the 18th by Gil Hanse with the PGA Tour's Steve Wenzloff doing all of the explaining at headquarters for the skeptical Oxford shirt set.
Dorman observed some play Tuesday and so far, so good.
With a large gallery in tow, Keegan Bradley, the St. John’s product and P.G.A. Championship winner, came to the tee and blasted a towering drive that looked, from the tee, perfect. It wound up in a grass finger in the left bunker, a position from which Bradley pitched to about 8 feet from the hole.
“I think it’s great,” Bradley said. “I think 70 percent of the field’s going to have a chance to go at it and drive it. I hate when they do drivable par 4s that are like an island green. You can legitimately go at this thing.”
Bradley’s line off the tee: driver over the trees right at the green.
“Right at it,” he enthused. “The cool thing is you can definitely make a 2 there if you hit a good drive.”
One player not so wild about the hole has also never met a design feature favoring long hitters that he's liked. Ryan Ballengee reports:
For Paul Goydos, though, the selection is clear on the tee. It’s a long iron for him and, he feels, most of the field.
When asked after his Tuesday practice round how much of the field might take a crack at driving the green, Goydos told me, “Probably 10 percent.”
He explained, “The penalty is too high if you don’t hit a good shot. If you miss, then you’re going to have a hard time making a four.”
The California native added, “I think there are guys who can definitely get there, but just not many. It’s an uphill 285 and at best into a crosswind.”
I had trouble finding pictures of what it looks like from the tee, but you can get some sense in this Brendan Prunty video interviewing Plainfield's Director of Golf, Scott Paris.
**Interesting strategic philosophy from Phil about how the hole sets up for him:
Q. Could I get your thoughts on 18 and your thoughts of ending the round on a drivable par 4, and what do you think of that hole?
PHIL MICKELSON: I think it's terrific. If I ask anybody to think of your favorite golf course, and on that golf course, to think of your favorite hole, it's either a par 3 under 150 yards or a drivable par 4, occasionally a reachable par 5.
That 18th hole is going to be one of the favorite holes for the guys. It gives us a chance to get aggressive, conceivably make an eagle, most likely make a birdie, and if you hit a bad shot, make a 5. I think that that makes it exciting for the finish.
You can look at it as a really long par 3 if you want. You can call it a short par 4, whatever par is, that hole is going to create some excitement. And the fact that just about everybody can reach it or get close, makes it really fun. Into the wind will be tough, though. Into the wind it's hard to reach.